Some of this may seem pretty darn ridiculous. This is because many people’s expectation for eating disorders is just that. I want to explore the general, uninformed thoughts of what someone with an eating disorder is like vs the reality of eating disorders. My hope is that this can help distinguish what is the truth.
- you look like a walking skeleton
- Eating disorders have no weight or size limit. Have you ever heard of BED, OSFED, BN? None of these disorders are defined by weight (and anorexia to an extent can be the same). You could be severely underweight or obese and still your struggle is valid.
- you believe you’re extremely fat
- Feeling you are fat definitely can be a factor of having an ED, but isn’t always. For example, one study found nearly 50% of “normal” BMI women believe they are overweight. Not even close to all of these women have eating disorders, and not everyone with an eating disorder even struggles with this belief.
- you order only salads and other”clean” foods
- Under the premise of judging mental health based on foods people eat, every vegan or vegetarian would be labeled as an ED patient. Heck, tons of people have salads daily simply because they enjoy them.
- you are an upper/middle class, white, adolescent or young adult woman
- So, in order to debunk the myth about who can have eating disorders, let me give you a sampling of who I’ve met in treatment: adolescent and young adult men, people of color, a 70-year-old woman, children from 8-12, people with lower-income, middle-aged men and women. Hopefully, you get the point.
- you are a vain person
- The fact that some believe vanity is central to an eating disorder kills me. This has nothing to do with thinking you’re better than someone else or putting yourself up on a pedestal. For the most part, people with EDs tend to think very little of themselves.
- you choose to have one
- If I chose to have this eating disorder, that means someone would choose to have cancer, Parkinson’s or kidney disease. It’s clearly just for all of the wonderful attention we receive.
- you just don’t eat
- Finally, the “you just don’t eat” argument. Quite obviously, no one will survive if they literally eat nothing for an extended period of time, so that’s automatically false. Adding onto it, this assumes that the only/easy way to have an eating disorder is by starving.
This first list is either outside focused or under the assumption that mind-reading is possible. News flash: no one has special mind-reading capabilities and can look into a person’s head to determine if an ED is present! An eating disorder is so much more than what you eat or look like. to me, the last three statements
- you are a person
- WHOA. So I’m telling you that just by being alive you can have an eating disorder?!? So weird, because you probably thought you must have some sort of obvious signs, maybe even a big blinking light. That would help.
- you have ANY disordered eating patterns (ex: binge eating, eating in secret, eliminating all “unsafe” foods, purging..)
- That’s right, folks. There is more than one disordered eating habit. The list here isn’t even comprehensive. Essentially, if something seems extremely out of the norm, it could be a sign of a subclinical or full-blown eating disorder.
- your everyday existence is ruled by thoughts of food, behaviors, exercise, body image, calories, etc
- Eating disorders are not something that only happens at meal time, while exercising, and as you look into the mirror. It encompasses your whole day (an average I’ve heard is around 12 hours a day!). Got a test tomorrow? Whatever you are studying will have the lovely background noise of the ED whispering or even screaming at you.
- you have a body
- Yet another mind-blowing fact. You only need a body? It doesn’t have to be a certain size or shape?
- you have mass
- Going along with what you look like, the amount you weigh is another false determinant for the presence of an eating disorder. EDs happen all across the BMI chart and a vast majority are in the normal-overweight range. (Another tidbit: BMI = bullshit meaningless information because it cannot begin to tell you a person’s health level.)
- going into the kitchen creates a huge amount of anxiety
- This is something that is pretty much a given. Whether you deal with binge eating, restriction, or anything in between, eating is a fear in some way. Since food is prepped and stored in the kitchen, it becomes a room full of all the anxiety.
- you have different physical symptoms due to a MENTAL illness
- I find this last one to be of utmost importance. No matter what someone may look like on the outside or even through their actions, you will never be able to tell what’s going on within. This is not a physical struggle, even though there are often physical results of the behaviors. So many people in this world have invisible illnesses – both mental and physical – that can only be seen by looking below the surface. You have to realize this when dealing with eating disorders as well.
I hope that this can serve as a (somewhat sarcastic) guide for those who aren’t quite sure what eating disorders are and aren’t. I hope that you have a few takeaways from it:
- Physical symptoms of anorexia are all too often used as a reference point in deciding whether someone has an eating disorder.
- It is way too easy to believe you can read minds and use this magical power to determine whether someone has an ED. News flash: mind-reading is impossible, even when someone shows *all* of the signs you know of.
- Eating disorders look different on everyone. A person of any gender, size, socioeconomic status, race, age, BMI, etc can be struggling. Never assume elsewise.
Thank you so much for reading! Do you have any others you would like to add?
2 thoughts on “You might have an eating disorder if… (stigma v reality)”
OMG, thank you for posting something like this! I am diagnosed with anorexia even though… (I’ll take some of the myths one at a time)
1. skeleton: I was an athlete and even though I was emaciated, I looked normal on the outside. However, I ended up with severe osteoporosis, wasted muscles and decrease of cognitions….. I could go on.
2. salads only: I feared fruits and veggies, still do. I only ate steak, nothing else. I knew fat burns fat so I tried to burn it all off resulting in emaciating (on the inside).. as listed.
3. young adult: I’m 53. I became anorexic at 20 but here I am 33 years later… going into treatment centers not a young adult but as a young senior (new term for middle age).
4. vanity: I put myself on the bottom rung of the latter, not even worth the space I take, hiding, disappearing. I avoid being noticed at all cost.
5. choosing: nope. Looking at my history it was inevitable. Plus, there is a genetic factor involved. Does a person choose to have diabetes or cancer?
6. don’t eat: well, we’d die wouldn’t we.
As mentioned in a different comment, I’m in iOP. Most of us are anorexics and bulimics, none of us are emaciated because we are all weight restored. One woman shared how alone she feels because she is a binge eater and large, quite large. May I have your permission to print your post out for her?
LikeLiked by 1 person
I absolutely love your comment!! Seriously I relate so well to your personal story. Thank you for sharing 🙂 I’m glad you like my post. Of course you may! I love being able to help others in any way I can; it’s part of why I blog.
LikeLiked by 1 person